Peat moss has been a favourite amongst gardeners for over 50 years now, however we’re urged to think about its affect and search for peat moss options. Cocoa coir is likely one of the hottest options round, however does it additionally include potential long-term considerations?
Sustainability is a key phrase in fashionable gardening and the affect of the rising medium we select is on the prime of the checklist of points that must be reconsidered. When contemplating which rising medium to make use of, it’s worthwhile to contemplate its advantages and the way it will assist your crops, in addition to the broader penalties.
We have a look at the professionals and cons of each peat moss and coco coir that will help you discover a resolution to this troublesome backyard drawback.
(Picture credit score: Getty/Kirisa99)
What’s Pete Moss?
Peat moss is a standard rising medium constituted of decomposing sphagnum moss that’s widespread in peat bogs. For the reason that mid-Twentieth century it has grow to be a preferred selection for enhancing soil well being and fertility primarily as a result of the medium is great at retaining water and vitamins.
Peat moss gardeners should buy so as to add to dwelling potting mixes, akin to Espoma PTM8 8-Quart Natural Peat Moss out there on Amazon (opens in new tab).
Advantages of Peat Moss
Peat is made up of partially decomposed crops and natural matter and this contributes to the truth that it’s excessive in vitamins and has robust water holding capability. It’s thought-about that peat moss can absorb 20 occasions its personal weight in water, which it’s going to then slowly launch to the crops. Along with its capability to carry water, peat moss can enhance soil construction in yard beds, raised beds, or container gardens.
Mary Virgo (opens in new tab)Clemson College City Horticulture Agent and Grasp Gardener Coordinator, says that peat moss is ‘simple to work with, cheap and readily available in shops’ and is ideal for every kind of makes use of within the backyard.
He provides: ‘Peat moss is often used to amend planting medium recipes/mixtures. It varies from seed beginning combine, potting combine and so forth. Peat moss can be used open air, combined right into a planting mattress and sometimes added to soil to lighten, aerate and assist retain moisture the place soil could also be compacted, and drainage is an issue.’
Peat moss may help with drainage
(Picture credit score: Getty/Zakyaroslav Photograph)
Mary Virgo (opens in new tab) A Clemson College City Horticulture Agent and holds a B.Sc. in Horticulture (2018), together with an M.Sc. in Plant and Environmental Sciences (2020). He has a variety of expertise, together with interning at Claude Monet’s Home and Backyard in France and educating plant ID and greenhouse manufacturing programs in graduate faculty. Mary is enthusiastic about rising lower flowers, decorative panorama crops, and figuring out native crops and plant communities in South Carolina.
Cons of Pete Moss
The primary drawback with peat moss is expounded to sustainability and gardeners around the globe are suggested to cease utilizing the fabric and search for options.
Gathering peat moss destroys habitat and such peat bogs take centuries to type and can’t be replenished shortly. As such, peatlands take up carbon dioxide, so destroying them contributes to international warming. The sale of peat and peat moss to beginner gardeners shall be banned within the UK by 2024. No such ban is on the horizon in North America, nonetheless, the place Canada is the supply of most peat moss available on the market.
Away from sustainability, one other destructive of peat moss is that it has a pH of round 3.5-4 – which is extra acidic than many crops desire – and might make the soil extra acidic over time.
What’s Coco Coir?
Cocoa coir has grow to be more and more widespread as an alternative choice to peat moss lately. The fabric is a by-product of coconut manufacturing, the place the fibers of coconut husks are processed right into a peat-like substance.
Cocoa coir is often used as a liner for hanging baskets and as an eco-friendly rising medium for each seed compost and potting combine. It’s purchased so as to add to dwelling compost mixes, akin to natural backyard coir from Burpee (opens in new tab).
You possibly can see biodegradable pots constituted of coir and it’s widespread as a hydroponic rising medium. In my final 5 years as knowledgeable gardener, the gardens I’ve labored on have primarily used peat-free compost with added coir for each beginning seeds and crops.
Cocoa coir is a by-product of coconut manufacturing
(Picture credit score: Getty/Maxims Grigorjevs)
Advantages of Cocoa Coir
Coir has an awesome water holding capability, it really holds extra water than peat moss, nevertheless it would not maintain that water in addition to peat moss. Nonetheless, rewetting is less complicated when dry than peat moss.
The pH of coir is much less acidic than that of peat moss, sometimes a pH of 5.8-6.8, making it near the best stage for a lot of crops. Coir can final a very long time within the soil because it decomposes slowly inside two or three years and it additionally improves the aeration of any kind of soil.
Coir has a excessive cation alternate capability, which means it shops vitamins till wanted by crops and releases them slowly over time. As a waste product from coconut manufacturing, and the truth that coconuts develop simply on timber, coir is all the time out there as a byproduct and is extra sustainable than peat moss.
Coir peat can be utilized in the identical manner as moss, akin to a potting soil, prime dressing or as a sort of mulch. Clemson College’s Mary Vargo added: ‘For individuals who wish to get away from utilizing a lot peat, cocoa coir is likely one of the few choices out there available on the market for seed beginning. It appears to be like and feels just like Pete Moss.’
Disadvantages of cocoa coir
One drawback of coir is that it would not have a lot in it for vitamins and requires additional fertilizer to supply crops with all of the vitamins they need. Though it holds water, it isn’t all the time evenly distributed. Soil might seem dry on the prime of a pot, for instance, however could also be moist on the backside – so all the time verify the soil when watering crops.
Coir typically comes as a compressed block that expands in quantity when water is added, so the fabric could be compacted when it dries. An instance of a coir block is the Natural Coconut Coir Focus Seed Beginning Soil 2-Pack in Burpee (opens in new tab).
There are additionally some questions concerning the total environmental affect of coir. Ruth Hayes, backyard specialist for Home and backyardSome cite considerations which can be raised by gardeners concerning the environmental and human prices of such options to peat moss.
He stated: ‘Farming within the Far East, elements of pure forests are being destroyed to make manner for palm plantations, the coir wants a variety of contemporary water to make it usable after which transport it around the globe, including to the carbon footprint.’
Ruth is the Gardening Editor of Newbie Gardening Journal and is horticulturally skilled with a qualification from the Royal Horticultural Society. for his work Residence and backyard And beginner backyardThe world’s oldest weekly gardening publication, it covers gardening duties to match every season, from sowing and planting, to pruning, pruning, coping with pests and ailments, and protecting houseplants wholesome.
There are questions on whether or not cocoa coir is as sustainable as folks first suppose
(Picture credit score: Getty/Leila Melhado)
Which elements do you have to use?
With regards to peat moss vs. coco coir, each merchandise have their professionals and cons, so it is necessary to weigh all of the components earlier than deciding which one is correct to your wants. This will rely in your scenario, for instance in case you have alkaline soil chances are you’ll desire peat moss because the crops will profit from its extra acidic pH. Whereas, location may also come into play, when you reside someplace dry chances are you’ll favor coco coir because it holds extra moisture than peat moss.
Each admit to contemplating sustainability or environmental affect, so there is no such thing as a excellent resolution in the meanwhile. Contemplate your wants, contemplate the affect and make the choice that most accurately fits you.
FAQs
Can I combine peat moss and cocoa coir?
Sure, peat moss and cocoa coir could be combined collectively. Each of those are nice additions to the soil and mix to supply many advantages. Collectively they are going to enhance the soil’s water-holding capability and enhance each drainage and aeration.
Utilizing coco coir with peat moss will cut back the acidity of the peat moss, which is useful for crops that desire a extra impartial pH. Testing the soil pH to assist get the correct ranges to your crops is really helpful and could be executed with a easy soil check equipment, out there from Amazon. (opens in new tab)
Peat moss and coco coir provide actual advantages for gardeners, however each include their drawbacks. For a lot of gardeners, determining what works for his or her crops and their sanity is an issue. I’ve discovered that coir-based composts have labored nicely for me as a result of, each within the backyard I’ve labored on and at dwelling, I’ve actively decreased my peat use lately.
